The Danger of Treating the Word “Disciple” as a Noun Instead of a Verb #94

J. Warner Wallace is a cold-case homicide detective, a Christian case maker and an author. – See more at:

He wrote the following blog post on December 10, 2014 about a new way to view disciple making. Discipleship verus mentoring! It is very good. Henry Luke 12/19/2014

The Danger of Treating the Word “Disciple” as a Noun Instead of a Verb

In my last post, I wrote about why Christian discipleship is critical to Christian survival. While I was typing the article in Microsoft Word, I used the verb, “discipling” several times. Each time I typed it, the program’s spell-check feature underlined it to warn me about an errant term. The vast archive of words stored in the program did not include the verb, “discipling”. I started to wonder if I had misspelled it or created a word in ignorance, so I Googled “discipling” for a definition. Here’s what I found at
Verb (used with object); discipled, discipling.
Archaic. To convert into a disciple.
Obsolete. To teach; train.

In modern usage, “disciple” appears to be nothing more than a noun; efforts to use the term in our culture as a verb are now deemed “archaic” and “obsolete”. Are these efforts just as archaic and obsolete within the Church? I hope not, but I have to admit, they seem to be. Last year I spoke at 73 events (166 individual talks) in 20 states and on 9 university campuses. I addressed 30,385 people, the majority of whom were church-attending Christians. I typically ask these audiences to tell me why they are Christians, and as I’ve reported here in the past, their answers are not encouraging. Most Christians have still not been exposed to Christian Case Making (apologetics) and aren’t even aware of the evidence supporting their beliefs. They’re accidental Christians. It appears most of the Church is undiscipled (another word unrecognized by spellcheck), at least in terms of their ability to defend what they believe. It’s time for the Church to return to its roots and start using the word “disciple” as a verb once again.

In the Book of Acts, Luke gives us a snapshot of Christian discipleship in the person of Paul. Remember Paul spent three years studying the Scripture and “connecting the dots” from the Old Testament to Jesus while in the desert of Arabia. He then spent time with Peter and James and didn’t take to the mission field until he confirmed the truth with the eyewitnesses (read Galatians 1:13 to 2:10). Once he was properly discipled, he demonstrated the focus of this discipleship process. Paul regularly entered local synagogues to argue for the Deity of Jesus from the Old Testament with people who knew their Scripture (see Acts 17). Paul spent time “explaining” and “proving” Jesus was the Messiah by comparing the Old Testament prophecies with the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. He was a masterful apologist to those who grew up in the Jewish faith.

Paul was also prepared to share the truth with non-believers. He and Barnabas encountered many non-Christians in Lystra and Iconium, two indigenous pagan communities (see Acts 14). They preached boldly using signs and wonders as the evidential foundation for their proclamations. In Athens, Paul demonstrated the fullness of his discipleship training, effectively communicating to a pagan community the truth of Christianity using analogies from their own pagan culture. Paul obviously knew what he believed, why he believed it, and how his beliefs measured up against the fallacies of the culture. Paul was well discipled.

The Church today often mistakes discipleship for mentorship.
Both are important to the life of Christians, but they are two different processes. When we think of mentorship, we typically think of a process of modelling. Those who are mentored take on the shape, attitude and appearance of those who mentor them. Mentors exist as examples for those they mentor. Discipleship may include mentoring, but doesn’t necessarily require direct contact with a mentor. Paul spent three years in Arabia and never mentioned a mentor. What was he doing there? He was studying the Scripture and reflecting on what he was learning. Discipleship can take place without a mentor if you have access to the truth and are willing to take the time to learn. I have been discipled by many great apologetics books, websites and resources, even though I’ve never met their authors personally. I is a similar discipleship resource for you.

But make no mistake about it, the Church must take discipling seriously.
It’s time to return to a form of Christian discipleship celebrating the life of the mind as the foundation for all other aspects of the Christian life. Ideas have consequences and no Christian behavior or response is possible without a rational foundation in the Scripture. When we are properly discipled, we understand the reasonable foundation for our beliefs and are ready to engage the world as Paul did in the first century. It’s time to start using the word “disciple” as a verb.

J. Warner Wallace is a Cold-Case Detective, a Christian Case Maker, and the author of Cold-Case Christianity
Comment on this blog, Subscribe to J. Warner’s Daily Email, or download the Cold-Case Christianity App from the iTunes Store or Android Marketplace.
58 3 62
– See more at:

This entry was posted in Discipleship Training, One2Won Discipleship Training and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The Danger of Treating the Word “Disciple” as a Noun Instead of a Verb #94

  1. myfourladies says:

    Interesting and a little provocative. Are we discipling or mentoring? Most likely a mix but need to focus on discipling.

  2. David L. Phillips says:

    Is the word “disciple” used as a verb anywhere in the NT? Jesus talked about making disciples, but did he talk about discipling? Several years ago, I was involved with a group who used the term “discipling” for “evangelizing,”

  3. David those are good questions. I used to use the words “mentor and mentoring” when describing One2Won discipleship training. Then it occurred to me that anyone can be a mentor but only a disciple can disciple another person. That is when I have tried to change the word from mentoring to discipling, however old habits are hard to break. As for “discipling’ and “evangelizing” Matthew 28:18-20 is very clear; Jesus said “Go make disciples” which includes evangelizing and discipling. However for the last 50 years or more Christians have focused on evangelizing and very little or none on discipling. I suggest reading John Dickerson’s book “The Great Evangelical Recession” and my August 2013 post by this same title. I believe that our only hope for America is One2Won discipleship training. See my post on how First Baptist Jacksonville, Fl is using discipleship training. There is great power in multiplication. See page 50 of Joe Whites book “One2Won Crosstraining”. Henry Luke December 31, 2015

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s